Full-fat, low-fat and fat-free all work, but it needs to be plain. The perfect lunch for me! https://www.yummly.com/recipes/caesar-salad-dressing-without-mayonnaise This deliciously easy and authentic Caesar salad dressing recipe (made with or without anchovies) gets its signature creamy texture from good quality mayonnaise and sour cream with the tang of red wine vinegar. Extra Virgin Olive Oil; Lemon Juice. This is my mother’s recipe for Non-Creamy Caesar Salad Dressing. This Homemade Caesar Dressing with No Anchovies is the perfect way to enjoy the last of the season’s heirloom cherry tomatoes and romaine. Creamy Caesar Dressing Recipe. Ingredients for Healthy Caesar Salad Dressing without Mayonnaise. Christine says: “What an absolutely stellar idea. Heavy on the garlic cloves, but light on the cream. No idea how I managed that one! Tonight I made this homemade caesar salad dressing to drench over a delicious Kale Caesar Salad and accompany some leftover Greek Chicken Kebabs I squirrelled away from last night’s dinner. And for those that turn their noses up to the little fishies, this is a caesar dressing with no anchovies! Make sure you PIN this no anchovy Caesar Dressing! You could also pair your salad with my insanely easy String Cheese Manicotti , rich and delicious Chicken Bacon Swiss Spaghetti Pizza or Quick and Easy Spinach and Ravioli Lasagna . The toasted almonds and dried cranberries from the Kale Caesar add the perfect touch to this Rich Creamy Madness! What goes with caesar salad. We already know you DON’T need mayo and you DO need yogurt, but here’s what else you need for this healthy no-mayo Caesar salad dressing: Plain Greek Yogurt. Homemade salad dressings are some of the easiest recipes any home cook should master.